Insurance
Home›Insurance›Industry & Deals›Captive agents weigh independence amid commission cuts…
Captive agents weigh independence amid commission cuts and carrier control
Agency leaders say leaving can boost revenue and control, but it may also mean starting over without premiums, commissions, or insurer infrastructure.
For captive insurance agents considering independence, industry guidance highlights a tradeoff: moving out of a single-carrier model can offer more freedom over revenue and product direction, but it can also force agents to rebuild their businesses from scratch, including premium flow, commissions, and operational support previously provided by the insurer. Insurance Business spoke with agency leaders who described frustration tied to commission cuts, changes in underwriting appetite, and tighter corporate controls. Dan Garzella, founder and CEO of Garzella Group and Darkhorse Insurance Brokers, said a Farmers Insurance strategy shift undermined commercial property business he had developed over four years. After spending 10 years in the captive channel and building a top-performing agency with nine employees across five states, Garzella said the experience underscored a core captive vulnerability, where an agent’s growth and compensation remain tied to the decisions of one insurer. Keith Captain, president of FirstChoice, a MarshBerry company, urged agents to separate emotional drivers from commercial ones. He said some people frame independence as a reaction to commission cuts, but the first step should be defining why they want to leave and what kind of independent agency they plan to create, since that decision affects capital needs, staffing, technology, carrier relationships, and the types of business the agency pursues. Captain also contrasted outcomes for agents who do not own their books, noting that Nationwide’s transition of agents into independence involved moving agents with their existing books, with revenue already flowing. Garzella added that captive arrangements can provide substantial back office support, including accounting, along with branding and marketing, and he said independent founders must then select their own systems and reconcile commissions.